Open, focused, and your own

How to ask tarot a question

How to word a tarot question: open or closed, about yourself or others, and how to rewrite a weak question into a useful one.

Asking a question the cards can help with

The question shapes the whole reading. A clear question gives each card something to answer. A vague or loaded one leaves you guessing, or nudges you towards the answer you already wanted.

A good tarot question is usually open, about your own part in a situation, and specific enough to be useful. Plain words are fine. The work is in knowing what you really want to understand.

Open and closed questions

A closed question has a short answer, such as yes, no, or a date. “Will I get the job?” is closed. Tarot cards show situations and choices, and they rarely give a clean yes or no.

An open question asks for description. “What should I understand about this job application?” lets the cards show strengths, worries, and next steps. Questions that begin with what or how usually work best. Why questions can work too, though they can slide into blame.

Closed questions are still allowed. The page on yes or no tarot covers how people read them and why many readers rewrite them first.

Asking about yourself, and about other people

The cards are most useful when the question puts you at the centre. You can act on your own choices and feelings. You cannot check what someone else secretly thinks.

So instead of “What does he think of me?”, try “What do I want from this connection?” or “How can I find out where I stand?” The reading then deals with things you can see and change.

Asking about a relationship is fine. Reading about someone else’s health, money, or private life without their knowledge is intrusive, and the cards cannot check any of it. The page on reading responsibly says more.

Questions about timing

“When will I meet someone?” and “When will this end?” are among the most common questions. Some readers assign seasons or dates to the cards, using the suits or their astrological links, and their systems disagree. Arcanata does not treat the cards as a calendar.

A more useful timing question looks at what is in your hands: “What would help me feel ready?” or “What is slowing this down?” You can also give the reading a time frame, such as this month, so you can look back later and compare the reading with what happened.

Rewriting a weak question

Most weak questions can be rescued. Keep the worry behind the question and change its shape: make it open, put yourself at the centre, and narrow it to one situation.

Before: “Will we get back together?”

After: “What do I need to understand about why it ended, and about what I want now?”

Before: “Is he cheating on me?”

After: “What is making it hard to trust this relationship, and what could I ask him directly?”

Before: “Will I get the promotion?”

After: “How can I make the strongest case for the promotion?”

Before: “Should I quit my job?”

After: “What should I weigh up before deciding whether to leave my job?”

Before: “What will happen this year?”

After: “What would help me most in the coming year?”

Before: “Is something wrong with my health?”

After: “How can I look after myself while I wait for medical advice?”

A quick check before you draw

Read the question back to yourself. Could an answer help you act or understand? Are you ready to hear an answer you did not want? If the answer to either is no, wait, or ask a gentler question first.

Write the question down before you draw. It keeps the question from drifting while you read the cards, and it gives you something to check the reading against later.

Return to the tarot guide